Back When I Was a Studentβ¦
When I was in high school, I used to hear teachers say things like:
"If we give students calculators, they'll never learn how to do the math."
And honestly? I used to wonder:
"If we have a tool that helps us solve the problem⦠why aren't we allowed to use it?"
Now that I'm a math teacher, I still don't know if banning calculators is always the right move. But I'll be real with you β the main reason math teachers don't allow calculators all the time is simple: we don't fully trust you yet. π
We worry that if you're allowed to use a calculator all the time, you won't use your brain. You'll stop thinking. You'll let the tool do the work for you.
And now⦠we're having the same conversation about AI.
Let's Be Honest: AI Is Everywhere
AI tools can do a lot β they can write essays, draw pictures, make music, solve problems. They're fast. Convenient. Always available.
We all use them for something β and that's okay.
What's not okay is when we use AI in the wrong way.
What do I mean by "wrong"?
- π Using AI to think for us
- π Letting it write our homework
- π Completing tasks without learning anything
So here's the question you need to ask yourself:
Am I using AI the right way?
To answer that, think about what happens every time you use AI β whether for writing, math, or anything else:
- Did you actually learn something?
- Can you do it better next time, even without help?
If your answer is yes β well done! π
You're using AI the way it's meant to be used.
But if your answer is no, and you're just copying whatever the bot gives you and submitting it without checking or understanding⦠that's a problem. That's bad use of AI. And that's exactly why teachers are nervous about it.
Because when you let AI do all the work, you're not learning.
And if you're not learning, you're just
submitting answers β not understanding anything.
And honestly? That will catch up with you. In tests. In projects. In real life.
But Waitβ¦ What Even Is AI? π§
Think of it like this:
AI is a super tool β a kind of robot brain trained on a huge amount of information.
It doesn't think like you or me. But it can:
- Answer questions
- Explain topics
- Write summaries
- Help you organize ideas
- Solve math problems (yes, I know you've tried π )
It's not magic. It's not perfect.
But it's powerful β if you use it wisely.
Good AI vs. Bad AI (It's All About How You Use It)
Here's the difference between smart and lazy use:
- β Good use of AI:
- Practicing tricky problems
- Getting ideas for a project
- Asking for step-by-step explanations
- Checking your grammar or understanding
- Asking smart questions when you're stuck
- Getting a roadmap to learn a new skill
- β Not-so-good use:
- Copying entire assignments
- Letting AI do the thinking for you
- Submitting work you didn't even read
π‘ AI isn't your homework fairy.
It won't learn for you. That's your job.
And if you rely on it too much, your skills won't grow.
You'll feel it later β on tests, in group work, and
when you face real-world challenges.
Want to Use AI the Smart Way? π οΈ
Let's look at two students:
Student A uses AI like this:
Then they copy-paste the results without even checking.
Student B uses AI like this:
AI breaks it down. The student follows the steps, tries more questions, and learns how to do it on their own.
Here's roughly what good AI walks them through:
$$3(x - 2) = 12$$
$$3x - 6 = 12$$
$$3x = 18$$
$$x = 6$$
Notice the rhythm β distribute, isolate, divide. Once a student sees the pattern, they can solve $3(x + 5) = 21$ on their own. The same prompt that gave Student A an answer gave Student B a method.
Which one is learning?
Which one is growing?
That's what good AI usage looks like.
The Prompt Is Everything π
Most students who say "AI doesn't really help me" are just asking it the wrong way. The prompt you write decides whether AI does your homework or whether it teaches you to do it yourself. Same tool, totally different outcome.
Here's the upgrade, side by side:
- β "Write a 300-word essay about climate change." β β "I'm writing a 300-word essay arguing that cities should ban single-use plastic. Give me three strong arguments I haven't thought of, and one common counter-argument I should be ready to answer."
- β "Solve xΒ² β 5x + 6 = 0." β β "Walk me through factoring xΒ² β 5x + 6 = 0 step by step. After each step, ask me a small question to check if I'm following."
- β "Summarize this chapter." β β "I just read this chapter (pasted below). Quiz me with 5 short-answer questions, then tell me which ones I got wrong and why."
- β "Fix my code." β β "My code throws this error. Don't fix it for me. Explain what the error means and point to the line I should look at first."
See the pattern? The good prompts ask AI to be a tutor β to explain, to question you, to push back. The bad prompts ask it to be a vending machine. Vending machines don't make you smarter.
One More Thing You Need to Know: AI Lies π¬
This is the part most teachers don't say out loud, so I'll say it: AI is wrong all the time. Confidently wrong. It will give you a math answer with three correct steps and one quietly broken one. It will quote a book that doesn't exist. It will invent a historical fact that sounds completely plausible. There's even a name for it β hallucination.
This isn't a reason to stop using AI. It's a reason to never trust an AI answer you can't check.
- For math: redo the final step yourself, on paper, and see if it actually works.
- For facts: search the name, the date, the quote. If you can't find it on a real source, it didn't happen.
- For writing: read it out loud. If a sentence doesn't sound like something you would say or believe, don't put your name on it.
The students who'll do best in the next ten years aren't the ones who use AI the most. They're the ones who can tell when it's wrong. That's a skill. Practice it now, while the stakes are just a homework grade β not a job, a contract, or a medical decision.
Why This Matters for Your Future π
AI is already part of today's world β and it's not going away.
In the future, almost every job will involve AI somehow. The students who know how to use AI the right way will have a huge advantage.
But it's not just about jobs.
- Learning how to ask better questions.
- Thinking critically about what you read.
- Evaluating information and making decisions.
These are all life skills β and using AI properly helps you practice them.
The goal isn't to let AI do your thinking.
The goal is to become the kind of person who can use powerful
tools to think even better.
Final Thoughts: Use AI Like a Pro, Not a Shortcut π
People are saying, "AI will replace humans."
No β AI won't replace you. But someone who knows how to use AI
might.
So learn the tools.
Practice using them smartly.
Don't let them replace your brain β let them support
your brain.
Because calculators didn't kill math.
The internet didn't kill thinking.
And AI won't stop you from
learning β unless you let it.
- π Use AI to help you.
- π Use it to learn more.
- π Use it to become better.
The future is full of smart tools. But you?
You're the smartest tool in the room. π
A note for fellow teachers and parents π¨βπ«
Banning AI from a kid's life right now is like banning the internet in 2005 β it doesn't protect them, it just leaves them less prepared than the kids who weren't banned. They'll meet AI anyway. The question is whether they meet it with us, or alone in their bedroom at 11 p.m. the night homework is due.
What's been working for me: I let my students use AI for a specific task, then I ask them to show me the prompt they used and explain why they trusted (or didn't trust) the answer. The tool stops being a cheat machine. It becomes part of the lesson. We're not training kids who can't function without AI; we're training kids who can see through AI when it's lazy or wrong.
And to parents: don't ask "did you use AI for this?" Ask "what part of this did you understand the least?" That second question is the one that actually tells you something.
~ Salah Alkmali